Injured in an accident and unsure whether you need a lawyer? Misconceptions about hiring a personal injury attorney can lead to costly mistakes and lost compensation. At Hecht, Kleeger & Damashek, P.C., our NYC injury lawyers help clients across New York make informed decisions about their legal rights—starting with the truth.
Below, we break down the top myths about hiring a personal injury lawyer in NYC and explain why trusted legal guidance can make all the difference after an accident. If you are injured in any type of accident due to another’s negligence, (212) 490-5700 or use our online form to schedule a free consultation today. No fees unless we win.
Myth #1: “My Injuries Weren’t Severe Enough to Need a Lawyer”
In the event of an injury, you could believe you weren’t hurt that badly. However, in many instances, minor injuries could mask more severe ones. You could experience delayed symptoms, or your injuries might take a while to become noticeable. Traumatic brain injuries can have lifelong consequences, but it may take time for them to become apparent.
Common accident-related injuries that often seem minor at first
- Whiplash and soft tissue injuries – often from rear-end collisions, with pain developing days later
- Spinal cord injuries – including herniated or bulging discs that may require surgery
- Back and neck injuries – such as strains, sprains, or vertebral damage
- Concussions and closed head injuries – which may not show symptoms immediately but can impair memory and cognitive function
- Internal bleeding or organ damage – potentially life-threatening if undiagnosed
- Knee and joint injuries – including torn ligaments or cartilage that affect long-term mobility
- Fractures and dislocations – even minor fractures can require extensive rehab
- Emotional trauma or PTSD – especially after violent or traumatic accidents
If you choose not to pursue a claim, you could be left footing the bill for significant injuries that change your way of life. A personal injury lawyer can evaluate the full scope of your damages and help identify who is financially responsible.
Myth #2: “I Don’t Need a Lawyer to File a Claim”
Technically, this is true. However, you stand a better chance of recovering compensation successfully with the knowledge and backing of a personal injury lawyer. When you file a claim with an insurance company, an insurance adjuster can determine the value of your claim. Their goal is to keep their client’s costs low.
Our lawyers understand how insurance claims and adjusters work. They can guide you through the process and ensure you reach the best solution to recover compensation.
Myth #3:“Hiring a Lawyer is Expensive”
Personal injury attorneys understand that demanding a fee “out of pocket” is daunting to most clients. That’s why many operate on a contingency fee basis. That means you don’t pay unless your lawsuit or claim is successful. A lawyer may take some of your settlement, but winning the settlement incentivizes your lawyer to win. Working with a lawyer can boost your final payout instead of working alone.
Lawyers are operating a business. The cost of doing business might seem steep, but good lawyers warrant good prices. The final cost shouldn’t come as a surprise: a trustworthy lawyer will outline their pricing and explain what you owe before the final bill comes due.
Myth #4:“I have Plenty of Time to Hire a Lawyer for a Claim”
After you’re hurt in an accident, you might feel you have all the time to file a claim with the person who injured you. New York’s Statute of Limitations gives you three years to file a personal injury lawsuit. Your time to hire a lawyer is even less than that.
A personal injury lawyer will need time to investigate your case to prove effectively that you were injured by someone’s negligence. Lawyers benefit by having more time to research and build a case. You need to consider hiring a lawyer as soon as you believe you won’t receive the maximum compensation for your damages.
Myth #5: “The Insurance Company has to Pay for My Damages”
It’s a common misconception that insurance companies are there for the consumer. They are companies designed to generate revenue. They will look for ways to reduce or avoid any payout. An insurance company may offer a “lowball settlement” to skimp on your payment.
It could be tempting to accept the initial settlement. You might want some help in the short run or maybe you want the whole process to be over. Most insurance companies hope you’ll take the offer because you might not know better about your claim’s true cost.
A lawyer can negotiate a higher payout and hold an insurance company accountable. You need to consider your future costs: if your injuries worsen or your life changes radically, you could need more than that lowball settlement provides.
Myth #6:“Lawyers Complicate Cases to Get Paid More”
Filing insurance claims and pursuing lawsuits gets complicated. Each case is unique. While the procedure might be similar between cases, the necessary steps to reach a positive outcome might be very different.
A personal injury attorney is going to work towards your best interests to secure a win. Lawyers working on a contingency fee handle the upfront costs. If they suggest hiring a private investigator to shore up your case, or file additional motions in your lawsuit, it should be to win. A lawyer working in your best interest won’t “inflate” a case with frivolous motions. Instead, they’ll use effective litigation to secure a win.
Myth #7: “I Can Hire Any Lawyer Because They’re All the Same”
There’s an idea that any lawyer can handle any case. When you’re dealing with a personal injury case, you want an attorney who focuses on personal injury law. It’s like going to see a medical specialist: a dentist might have an idea how to treat your sinus issue, but an ear-nose-and-throat doctor will give you a better diagnosis and a better chance of successful treatment.
Our injury lawyers understand the personal injury process, nuances of New York’s laws, and they can help you pursue compensation after an accident.
Debunk the Myths. Get the Legal Help You Deserve.
At Hecht, Kleeger & Damashek, P.C., we know hiring a lawyer is a big decision. We work with clients like you every day and want you to trust us. We’re ready to help you debunk any misconceptions about working with lawyers. We want you to succeed in your personal injury case and hold those negligent actors responsible for your damages.
We have helped clients in similar situations recover millions in the past. Rely on our experience and knowledge of New York’s personal injury laws to recover your life.
FAQ: Hiring a Personal Injury Lawyer in New York
When Should I Hire a Personal Injury Lawyer?
You should contact a lawyer as soon as possible after seeking medical attention—ideally within days of the accident. Early legal help ensures proper documentation, protects your rights, and improves your negotiating position.
How Much Does It Cost to Hire a Personal Injury Lawyer?
Nothing upfront. Most New York personal injury attorneys work on a contingency fee, meaning they only get paid if you do. The fee is usually a percentage of your final settlement or court award.
Do All Personal Injury Cases Go to Court?
No. In fact, over 90% of cases settle out of court. A skilled attorney can often resolve your case through negotiations—but they’ll prepare your case fro trial if necessary.
What Happens If I Wait Too Long to File a Claim?
You could lose your right to recover damages entirely. New York’s three-year statute of limitations applies to most injury claims, but some cases—like those involving public entities—have even shorter deadlines.
Can I Handle My Case Without a Lawyer?
Technically, yes—but you risk being underpaid. Insurance companies often offer significantly lower settlements to unrepresented claimants. A lawyer helps you level the playing field.
Hurt in NYC? get a Free Consult at HKD
Hecht, Kleeger & Damashek, P.C. is an award-winning personal injury law firm based in Midtown Manhattan, serving clients throughout Manhattan, Brooklyn, the Bronx, Queens, and Staten Island.
Our NYC injury attorneys are Elite Lawyers, Million Dollar Advocates, and respected trial lawyers who have recovered hundreds of millions of dollars for accident victims. We fight for maximum compensation and understand how New York juries and insurance companies operate. Don’t wait—you may have limited time to file a claim. Work with a personal injury lawyer in NYC who make a difference in and out of court. Schedule your free consultation today.
Call (212) 490-5700 or use our online form to schedule a consultation today. No fees unless we win.